Highest Rated Non-gmo Protein Powders for 2025
Find the highest rated protein with top customer reviews in the non-gmo category. Compare products by price, protein content, and customer reviews.
🏆 Top 10 Highest Rated Non-gmo Proteins (Analyzed 2139 Products)
| Product | Brand | Rating | Price | Protein/$ | Shop |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 Absorb Plus Elemental Shake Isolate Protein BEST VALUE | Absorb Plus | 5 | $12.95 | 2.1g | View |
 swiig Premium Daily Whey Protein Matrix | swiig | 5 | $351.99 | 18.2g | View |
 RNWY Protein + Creatine Powder | RNWY | 5 | $44.99 | 11.7g | View |
 Nokuba Collagen Protein Coffee Creamer Powder, Marine Collagen Peptides with Coconut Mct Oil for Hair Skin & Nails Support | Nokuba | 4.8 | $109.99 | 6.0g | View |
 Natural Factors Whey Factors Grass Fed Whey Protein Concentrate | Natural Factors | 4.8 | $43.37 | 14.9g | View |
 Venture Pal Multi Collagen Protein Powder | Venture Pal | 4.8 | $25.99 | 10.4g | View |
 Fernes Hydrolyzed Collagen Peptides Supplement Type I & III | Fernes | 4.7 | $49 | 25.0g | View |
 NAKED Nutrition Whey Isolate Protein Powder | NAKED | 4.7 | $51.99 | 16.2g | View |
 Mt. Capra Deep 30 Meal Replacement Shake Goat Protein Powder | Mt Capra | 4.7 | $62.1 | 8.2g | View |
 LEGION Whey Concentrate Protein Powder | LEGION | 4.7 | $44.99 | 13.3g | View |
Want to explore more options?
We analyzed 670 products to bring you these top 670 non-gmo options. Use our advanced filters to explore all products and find your perfect match.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the cheapest non-gmo protein?
The cheapest option is Jive 100% Grass Fed Protein Hydrator Clear Protein Powder at $1.99. However, Absorb Plus Elemental Shake Isolate Protein offers better value at 2.1g protein per dollar.
How much should I expect to pay?
Non-gmo protein powders range from $1.99 to $351.99, with an average price of $48. Quality products typically fall between $38-$58.
Which brands make non-gmo protein?
Top brands include Orgain, NaturesPlus, Garden of Life and 7 others. We track 10 different brands offering quality non-gmo products.
How do I choose the best value?
Focus on protein per dollar (aim for 11.4g/$ or higher), check ratings and reviews, and consider your dietary needs. Our #1 pick Absorb Plus Elemental Shake Isolate Protein offers excellent value at 2.1g per dollar.